Shrill – A Television Review
Television Review/Slight life crisis.
Annie. Annie. Annie. Annie.
Hello, Annie’s fat, and so are a lot of other characters in this show and it makes me happy.

Hulu’s Original Shrill is about a young writer trying to get her life together without a makeover. Because let’s be real, the actress who plays Annie, Aidy Bryant, is already as lovely as can be. While the show focuses on Annie’s personal and professional relationships, and how they quickly go to shit when she starts to view herself in a different light, the topic of her weight is not something that is ignored. Because a plus sized woman out in the world and media is something no one is silent ever about. Shrill tackles the weight problem, not by having a weight loss montage and shots of kale smoothies, but by looking at the inner struggles of being a fat person and the social stigmas that come with it. When you’re fat everyone feels obligated to give you tips on how to lose weight, even if they have never stepped foot in a gym. When you’re fat people feel sorry for you. When you’re fat people think you’re less intelligent. When you’re fat people think you don’t take care of yourself. When you’re fat people think you don’t fucking notice you’re fat.
This show pushes all the people who have said and posted things like this into the light, proving them wrong and giving them one giant middle finger.
In episode four there is a pool party focused on celebrating all body types. Annie’s asshat boss deems the party it irrelevant for an article, but Annie goes anyway to scope it out. When she gets there, camera shots focus on women dancing carefree, thighs giggling, laughter, and beauty in a verity of shapes and sizes. I’ve dealt with the pool party shame, as I’m sure a lot of people with body image issues have, watching this scene was cathartic for me.

One thing (among many)I need to commend Shrill for doing is showing that women over a certain size are desirable. Emotionally, yes, romantically yes, and SEXUALLY (and not in a fetishizing way). In a normal, this is what real life is, fat people have sex, fat people are sexy, kind of way. Growing up as a fat kid, I always thought that I needed to find someone who would love me ‘despite’ my body, it was not a concept even known to me that someone like me could be loved for more than the personality I worked so hard on (because I knew I was fat so I had to work on other qualities to bring up my value as a human being and compensate for the nose I hadn’t grown into) I wasn’t taught that someone could love you for every part of me. That a fat fetish isn’t needed for someone to be attracted to me.
This brings me to the love interest, Ryan. And let me tell you, we hate Ryan. This isn’t a spoiler, in the first moment we meet Ryan we are introduced to the fact that he is a human bag of dirt. I think the most painful thing about him is that we’ve all had a Ryan in our lives. Maybe a few of them, maybe one right now (in that case please call me and I’ll yell at you until you dump him). To be honest, I hated this guy so much I barely got through the first episode. He hit home so intensely that I texted my best friend (hi, Sara) because she had watched the show and asked her if Ryan and Annie broke up eventually, she said they did, so I continued watching only to find out that after rough patch they get back together. Sara, having lied to me, got some very angry messages (hi, again).
Ryan, the man-child who needs to be babysat constantly and uses Annie to function (barely) in society. Girl, he’s gotta GO.
Annie’s character also frustrated me because I saw a lot of myself in her. Making excuses for a guy that has the personality of the color beige. Being selfish about what’s going on in her life (in her defense, she was always putting others before herself, so now she’s trying to love herself and find a balance). Her sense of humor. Her sense of self-worth. Putting up with people’s bullshit because she thinks if she doesn’t they will cast her out. Her relationship with Fran. I saw bits and pieces of myself scattered in this show. I was happy to be a part of it, watching Annie go through ups and downs and finally start on the path to being comfortable with herself. I’m hopeful and excited to watch the next season with it comes out next year, maybe Annie and I will be caught up with each other on our journey.
Shrill is a witty, emotionally driven, one of a kind show and I think you should check it out if you haven’t already. If you have, I’d love to have a discussion with you in the comments.
Thanks for reading.
-Tina






